Internet backs woman who made her teenage niece feel like a ‘monster’

On-line commentators backed a lady who stated in a viral put up that she made her 17-year-old niece really feel like a “monster”.

Posting on the Reddit discussion board “Am I The A**gap” (AITA) below the username u/AcceptableAffect7090, the lady stated she misplaced her 15-year-old daughter final 12 months, and her niece in contrast that loss to the demise of her canine. In response, u/AcceptableAffect7090 “shouted” at her niece. The put up garnered greater than 8,600 upvotes and a whole lot of feedback criticizing the teenager’s insensitivity.

loss of a kid

Deborah Carr, PhD, chair of the Division of Sociology at Boston College, instructed Dad and mom that many contemplate the demise of a kid “the worst particular person stress an individual can expertise.”

“Dad and mom and oldsters particularly really feel accountable for a kid’s well-being,” Carr stated. “So after they lose a toddler, they not solely lose somebody they love. They’re additionally lacking out on the promising years they had been wanting ahead to.” .

Woman scolding young adult
Right here, a inventory picture of a lady scolding a younger grownup. On-line commentators backed a lady who stated in a viral put up that she made her 17-year-old niece really feel like a “monster”.
fizkes / istock

A number of consultants additionally instructed the publication that grief related to the loss of a kid is usually “extra intense” than “classical grief.”

“Within the first 12 months after shedding a toddler youthful than him, a guardian is extra more likely to commit suicide and all the things from extreme melancholy to sophisticated grief,” stated Dr. Jill Saltz, MD, a psychiatrist at New York Presbyterian Hospital, Weill Cornell College of Drugs. my father.

Saltz defined that “complicated grief” differs from “regular grief” in that “there are extra extreme signs, alternating with seemingly no signs – numbness – that are more likely to impair their capability to perform.”

Some dad and mom “be taught to reside with loss,” Carr added, whereas others “battle to search out which means in life.”


In her put up, u/AcceptableAffect7090 stated her 15-year-old daughter died in a automotive accident final 12 months, and though she is present process therapy, she can’t carry herself to go to her daughter’s room.

“I wasn’t capable of clear her room or get in, so it is simply because it was when she was alive,” she stated. “My husband does not go in there both, and we preserve the door closed.”

So when their niece came visiting final week, u/AcceptableAffect7090 and her teenage husband made a mattress on the sofa.

“I requested why she could not sleep within the ‘visitor room,’ and I instructed her we do not have one,” u/AcceptableAffect7090 wrote. “[My] Her niece stated she thought our daughter’s room was the visitor room now. I defined that we have not been capable of change something but, and she or he rolled her eyes and stated it was a 12 months in the past, and we [needed] to maneuver ahead.”

From there, issues obtained worse.

“Once I began crying, I attempted to apologize, and I feel in an effort to speak, she stated she had endured the lack of her canine so arduous however obtained over it inside a 12 months, and yelled that my baby shouldn’t be a canine,” u/AcceptableAffect7090 stated.

Redditor u/AppreableAffect7090’s husband despatched their niece residence, and her sister later accused her of being unreasonable.

“[She said] I’ve made [my] Your niece looks like a monster,” concluded u/AcceptableAffect7090. AITA? “

Redditors’ response

Redditors stated u/AcceptableAffect7090’s response was solely cheap and criticized her niece’s insensitivity.

“NTA [not the a**hole]. She wanted to be taught in some way that it’s by no means acceptable to equate the loss of a kid with the lack of a pet,” stated u/Sweeper1985. “You reacted with unhappiness, you actually cannot be blamed.”

u/nottheblackhat wrote: “She looks like a monster as a result of she acted like a monster. For a 17-year-old to be so merciless and merciless, she must face some penalties.”

Redditor u/Bl0ndeFox added: “NTA. 17-year-old ought to know higher… nonetheless grieving, and she or he was performing so impolite and insensitive. This would possibly sound imply, however your niece in all probability wanted to really feel that ‘being a monster’ “To get up slightly.”

NEWSWEEK u/AcceptableAffect7090 has been accessed for remark.

Extra viral posts

A pair sparked controversy on-line on Monday after they admitted refusing to pay their son’s tuition charges after he got here out as homosexual.

Redditors supported a teen who stated, on Monday, that she reached out to her organic father after studying she was the product of an affair.

And final week, commentators endorsed a person who instructed his youthful siblings about their mom’s secret affair, inflicting them to hate her.